Alternatives to protein powder when you're done with shakes

Sick of the shaker? Real alternatives to protein powder: whole foods, bars, ready-to-drink shakes and pre-digested protein tablets, and when each one fits.

Rated 4.9 by our customers
An athlete in a white Recov training shirt in the gym
Recov By RecovPublished · Last updated · 5 min read

The best alternatives to protein powder are protein-rich whole foods, protein bars, ready-to-drink shakes and pre-digested protein tablets. For protein without a shaker, Recov is the complete option: porcine plasma protein with all 20 amino acids, already broken down and pressed into tablets you swallow with water. There's nothing to mix, taste or wash.

About us: Recov is an Australian brand from Future Supplements Pty Limited. We built Recov Protein Concentrate for people who are done with shakes, and we've sold it since 2010: 180 tablets, from $79.95 a bottle on subscription.

Why do so many people give up on protein powder?

You know the routine. The tub on the bench, the scoop that's always buried, the shaker that smells of yesterday no matter how well you rinse it. You mix it after a session, drink it standing at the sink, and it sits heavy in your stomach on the drive to work. Then there's the flavour, which mostly exists to cover up the taste of the powder.

None of that makes protein less important. It just makes powder a chore, and a chore you skip is protein you don't get. So the real question is what gives you quality protein in a form you'll actually keep taking.

What can you replace protein powder with?

There are four real options, and each suits a different part of the day.

  1. Protein-rich whole foods. The base of every good diet.
  2. Protein bars. Easy to carry; check the label.
  3. Ready-to-drink (RTD) protein shakes. A shake without the mixing.
  4. Pre-digested protein tablets. Protein with no liquid at all.

How much protein do whole foods give you?

Food comes first, and the Australian Dietary Guidelines make it easy to plan. One standard serve from the lean meats and alternatives group is any of these:

  • 65 g cooked lean red meat, such as beef, lamb or pork
  • 80 g cooked lean chicken or turkey
  • 100 g cooked fish fillet, or one small can of fish
  • 2 large eggs (120 g)
  • 1 cup (150 g) cooked or canned legumes, such as lentils or chickpeas
  • 170 g tofu

Adults aged 19–50 are advised to have 2½ to 3 serves a day from this group, alongside dairy or alternatives. The NHMRC Nutrient Reference Values set the recommended protein intake for adults aged 19–70 at 0.84 g per kilogram of body weight a day for men and 0.75 g/kg for women. People who train need more. The 2016 joint position statement from the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics, Dietitians of Canada and the American College of Sports Medicine puts athletes at 1.2–2.0 g/kg.

The catch with food is logistics. Cooked chicken doesn't live in a gym bag, and a 5am session doesn't leave time for eggs.

Pre-digested plasma peptides. All 20 amino acids, absorbed in 15–25 min.

Recov Protein Concentrate

Shop Recov →From $2.67/day · free shipping over $99 · pause or cancel anytime

Are protein bars and ready-to-drink shakes good alternatives?

They solve the mixing problem. Whether they suit you comes down to the label:

  • Bars vary widely. Check the sugar, the sweeteners and the protein source, including whether it's dairy.
  • RTD shakes remove the scoop, but you're still drinking a shake. Check the protein source and the flavouring.

Both work well as an occasional convenience. As a daily habit, you're usually back to flavours, sweeteners and whole protein your gut still has to spend hours digesting.

Can you take protein as tablets instead?

Yes, and this is the option most people don't know exists. Recov is an Australian brand from Future Supplements Pty Limited. It has been sold since 2010 and is made to EU manufacturing standards. It isn't a powder pressed into a pill. It's porcine plasma protein pre-digested into di- and tri-peptides, the size your gut takes up directly through a transporter called PEPT1. It reaches the bloodstream in 15–25 minutes, with no heavy shake to digest first.

We call this the Bi-Peptide Window. Your whole bloodstream carries only 2–3g of amino acids at any moment. Six tablets of Recov deliver roughly that entire amount, already broken down into small peptides your body absorbs directly. Peptides are burned for energy about ten times more slowly than free amino acids, so more of every tablet goes to work. The science page explains the route in full.

It's a complete protein with all 20 amino acids. It's dairy-free and lactose-free, with no sweeteners, flavours or proprietary blends. And it's portable: a 180-tablet bottle goes anywhere.

One customer, Joel C., put the switch plainly in a review on recovfaster.com:

Joel C.Review on recovfaster.com

I switched to Recov because it was more convenient in my busy lifestyle taking tablets, rather than drinking shakes, which left me feeling bloated and sick.

What's the easiest protein to take when you travel?

Anything without liquid. Powders mean decanting into bags or packing a tub. Shakes and RTDs add weight and have to stay upright. Tablets go in a pocket, a carry-on or a desk drawer, and you take them with a glass of water. Recov's 180-tablet bottle lasts 30 days at six a day.

Why do dietitians say no to protein powder?

Mostly they say "food first", and they're right. A supplement fills the gaps that food leaves, and the 2016 position statement recommends a regular spread of high-quality protein across the day. The practical gap for most people is the hours around training, travel and long workdays, when a proper meal isn't possible. That's the job Recov is built for: complete protein that fits into those hours, alongside a protein-rich diet.

How do you choose the right alternative?

  • You like cooking and eat regular meals: lean into whole foods and cover the busy hours with Recov.
  • You need something between meetings or on the road: Recov, because there's nothing to carry but the bottle.
  • You want a shake with breakfast anyway: keep it, and use Recov around training.
  • You want protein before a session with no heaviness: Recov. Take four tablets about 30 minutes before and two straight after.

Frequently asked questions

What can I replace my protein powder with?

Protein-rich meals, protein bars, ready-to-drink shakes, or pre-digested protein tablets like Recov, the only one of those with nothing to mix or drink.

What is a good alternative to protein shakes?

If you want to skip liquids altogether, protein tablets. Recov is a complete protein with all 20 amino acids that you swallow with water.

Is Recov as good as whey?

Recov does something standard whey doesn't. It arrives already broken down into the peptides your gut absorbs directly, reaching your bloodstream in 15–25 minutes, with no dairy and nothing to mix.

How many Recov tablets do I take?

Six a day is the standard, 8–12 on training days, and 12–18 in the heaviest training blocks. The label sets a serve at four tablets.

Who shouldn't take Recov?

Anyone who avoids pork, including vegetarians and vegans and people following halal or kosher diets. If you're pregnant, breastfeeding, managing a health condition or taking prescription medication, check with your health professional first. More in the FAQ.

How much does it cost?

A bottle is $119.95 one-time, or from $79.95 a bottle on subscription, which you can pause or cancel anytime. Your first order is covered by a money-back guarantee. See Recov Protein Concentrate.

Anti-doping bodies do not approve or endorse any supplement; if you are drug-tested, check Recov with your sporting body before you take it. Always read the label and follow the directions for use. Individual results vary.

Sources